The Good Girl's Guide Blog
Our experiences living with our guys. The behind-the-scenes scoop on promoting our book. And plenty of talk about relationships.

A Jewish Girl and a Christmas Tree Walk into a Bar

Monday, 15 December 2008 12:13 by joselinlinder
I think these blog entries are starting to have something of a theme. However, while I don’t fancy a Pope picture on my wall (see the last entry and the one before last), I also don’t consider myself religious. The truth is, when people say things like, “Oh, I think of myself as spiritual rather than religious,” I have this urge to punch them, so I’m probably not even really so, ugh, spiritual. I am however, vaguely freaked out that right now there is a big, if festive Christmas tree in my living room.
    
In trying to explain this to Aaron I said that not having a Christmas tree to some Jewish families is what having them is to Christmas-celebrating households: special. I know, I know, a lot of Jews (especially ones from Cincinnati) have Christmas trees and Hanukah bushes as readily as any other red-blooded American. Some even decorate with lights on the outside of their homes. But while my family enjoyed a good Christmas Eve light-seeing trip, we never had lights of our own except for those specific to the festival thereof.

So my anxiety about this tree is not at all a bah humbug whine-fest, but more like, something that doesn’t fit quite right. Of course, Aaron got it all up in his craw that not wanting a Christmas tree could be likened to, say, steeling a Baby Jesus from a Nativity scene. Therefore, I gave in, as long as I could pick it. So I did. And it’s awesome and bushy and the kind with the long pretty needles instead of the short ones. This is a very huggable tree.

I know what you’re thinking, a girl who speaks of her tree so effusively must secretly in her heart have always wanted a Christmas tree of her very own. And I’m not going to lie—I was really excited by the mini-Elvis painting and orange glitter pistol ornaments I scored at Urban Outfitters (my new favorite store since discovering their non-Christian-y and even non-Christmas-sy ornament collection as well as learning last week that they will carry my new book The Purity Test come February!!). But the truth of the matter is that Aaron and I are trying to share a home, and I have as much of a responsibility as he does to find a way to create holidays that belong to us both.

I think if I’d really put my foot down, Aaron would have accepted a tree-less holiday. But I also think it would have put a damper on our first holiday season as a cohabitating couple. I remember hearing once about an interfaith family whose philosophy is to take all the good things about all the holidays and make them into something new and special that belonged to all of them. I have also heard a very sound piece of advice from another couple merging two religions into one household: It is all about respect. I don’t have to believe in any religious aspect of Christmas to respect it. In fact, I don’t even need to get a Christmas tree. But for the record, the menorah, a bag of Hanukah gelt and a picture of my great-grandfather, Rabbi Morris Furman are right beside it. And believe me, Aaron is respecting the hell out of them all.

(I’d also like to say for the record that I have never stolen a Baby Jesus, tackled a blow up Santa nor have I tried to drunkenly ride an animatronic reindeer. I know the words to almost all the Christmas standards and am willing to sing them in and around school choirs. But despite not hating and even pretty much enjoying Christmas and the time of year in general, I am still raising the dog Jewish. But I have to admit, our home this holiday season is lovely.)

Be the first to rate this post

  • Currently 0/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Tags:   ,
Categories:   book | cohabitation | Joselin & Aaron
Actions:   E-mail | Permalink | Comments (4) | Comment RSSRSS comment feed

Related posts

Comments

February 18. 2009 07:28

Danette

Why won't my Jewish boyfriend let me get an Xmas tree?? I'm not even Christian myself, I'm Buddhist - but I just like the way they smell! (They're a pagan tradition anyway)

So Joselin I'm thinking maybe you can talk to him about compromise, and not being such a big Grinch...

Danette

February 18. 2009 15:18

Josie

I saw the tree with my own eyes!
But I heard the Baby Jesus near your home is missing. I didn't have enough time alone in your apartment to conduct a search.

Josie

March 11. 2009 23:43

Joselin

Sorry I'm late getting back to you, but Danette, spend this year working on him. You have a lot of days. I'd say every time you see a tree you should comment on how great it would look in your house! Then by next year you could probably work something out like bulbs on a ficas or tinsel on fern.

But seriously, the best way to navigate two different sets of holidays is with a lot of respect. If it is just about a nice smell, get a good air freshener or a bunch of pine branches to put in a big pot. But if you really miss your tree, like the celebration of it, the importance of it, then you guys should figure out a place in the house where it belongs to YOU! If you were just his roommate he would feel differently. It is because you guys are SHARING a home and not just like living in a space together that this is an issue...We'll talk more next yearSmile xo

Joselin

March 11. 2009 23:44

Joselin

And Josie, about the baby Jesus, well I have an alibi and it's a good one so I'm just saying...wait. Look over there! (runs out of the room.)

Joselin

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)  

  Country flag

[b][/b] - [i][/i] - [u][/u]- [quote][/quote]



Live preview

September 8. 2010 12:58